Rough and Tumble Straight Guy: Who played it best?

(L. to R.) Matty Strong, Blake Ryder and Steve Rogers

Tattoos, scruff, muscles and a healthy dose of "butch" are the main characteristics of the archetypical rough straight guy unwittingly seduced into gay sex. Blake Ryder from Men.com and Matty Strong and Steve Rogers from Next Door Studios check all the boxes required for the role, but which one was the most convincing as the rough and tumble straight guy?